Bet Better BET BETTER PRO

The most overrated and underrated teams of 2026

Before every game, the betting market says how much a team is expected to win or lose by. Then the game is played. Do that all season, add up the difference, and you can see which teams kept doing better than the market asked of them, and which kept doing worse.

2026 season · finished games up to 2026-11-15 · updated every few hours · free to reuse under CC BY 4.0 with attribution

9
leagues with enough finished games
5+
finished games behind every team shown
+0.8
most underrated: Arizona Diamondbacks (runs per game)
-1.1
most overrated: Seattle Mariners (runs per game)

How to read the number

Say the market expected a team to win by 3 and they won by 5. That is +2 for that game. Lose by 1 when they were expected to win by 3, and that is −4. We do that for every finished game and take the average.

  • A plus number = underrated. The market kept asking for less than the team delivered.
  • A minus number = overrated. The market kept expecting more than the team delivered.
  • It is not a win-loss record. A losing team can be underrated if it kept losing by less than expected.

Baseball (MLB)

30 teams, 2432 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are runs per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesruns per game vs expected
1 Arizona Diamondbacks 79 +0.8
2 Detroit Tigers 78 +0.7
3 Chicago White Sox 87 +0.6
4 San Diego Padres 86 +0.6
5 New York Mets 78 +0.6
6 Washington Nationals 77 +0.5
7 Chicago Cubs 80 +0.5
8 Los Angeles Angels 77 +0.5
9 San Francisco Giants 79 +0.4
10 Kansas City Royals 77 +0.3

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Arizona Diamondbacks to do one thing, and over 79 games they did +0.8 run per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesruns per game vs expected
1 Seattle Mariners 77 -1.1
2 Athletics 78 -0.9
3 Los Angeles Dodgers 86 -0.9
4 Philadelphia Phillies 81 -0.8
5 Texas Rangers 78 -0.6
6 Cincinnati Reds 80 -0.5
7 Houston Astros 78 -0.4
8 Toronto Blue Jays 78 -0.3
9 Cleveland Guardians 89 -0.2
10 New York Yankees 83 -0.1

College football

131 teams, 1200 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are points per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 Wake Forest Demon Deacons 10 +20.4
2 New Mexico Lobos 7 +16.5
3 Duke Blue Devils 9 +10.9
4 Louisiana Tech Bulldogs 8 +10.7
5 UCLA Bruins 10 +10.7
6 Liberty Flames 8 +9.2
7 Tulsa Golden Hurricane 8 +8.4
8 Oregon State Beavers 10 +8.0
9 Oklahoma State Cowboys 9 +7.8
10 Iowa Hawkeyes 9 +7.4

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Wake Forest Demon Deacons to do one thing, and over 10 games they did +20.4 points per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 California Golden Bears 10 -10.4
2 Old Dominion Monarchs 9 -9.8
3 Stanford Cardinal 8 -9.4
4 Michigan Wolverines 10 -8.1
5 Marshall Thundering Herd 8 -7.8
6 San Diego State Aztecs 9 -7.7
7 Eastern Michigan Eagles 8 -7.5
8 Kansas State Wildcats 9 -7.1
9 UTEP Miners 7 -7.0
10 UNLV Rebels 8 -6.7

Basketball (WNBA)

15 teams, 354 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are points per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 Atlanta Dream 32 +3.8
2 Washington Mystics 25 +2.7
3 Portland Fire 21 +2.7
4 Golden State Valkyries 33 +1.6
5 Los Angeles Sparks 22 +1.3
6 Dallas Wings 23 +0.4
7 New York Liberty 25 +0.3

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Atlanta Dream to do one thing, and over 32 games they did +3.8 points per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 Toronto Tempo 21 -5.7
2 Minnesota Lynx 22 -4.1
3 Seattle Storm 19 -2.7
4 Connecticut Sun 21 -2.2
5 Chicago Sky 21 -1.5
6 Phoenix Mercury 19 -0.8
7 Las Vegas Aces 26 +0.2

Football (MLS)

23 teams, 294 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are goals per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Charlotte FC 10 +1.2
2 Nashville SC 12 +0.9
3 FC Dallas 13 +0.5
4 Philadelphia Union 14 +0.5
5 Seattle Sounders FC 11 +0.5
6 Orlando City SC 13 +0.2
7 LA Galaxy 12 +0.1
8 New England Revolution 12 +0.0
9 Real Salt Lake 15 +0.0
10 St. Louis CITY SC 12 +0.0

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Charlotte FC to do one thing, and over 10 games they did +1.2 goals per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 D.C. United 11 -1.2
2 Inter Miami CF 12 -0.5
3 San Jose Earthquakes 14 -0.5
4 FC Cincinnati 14 -0.3
5 Colorado Rapids 12 -0.3
6 San Diego FC 13 -0.2
7 Sporting Kansas City 13 -0.2
8 Toronto FC 13 -0.2
9 Atlanta United FC 13 -0.1
10 Minnesota United FC 14 -0.1

NFL

32 teams, 272 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are points per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 Jacksonville Jaguars 8 +8.9
2 San Francisco 49ers 8 +5.5
3 Buffalo Bills 7 +4.9
4 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 9 +4.8
5 Chicago Bears 9 +4.6
6 Cincinnati Bengals 8 +3.9
7 New York Giants 9 +2.9
8 Pittsburgh Steelers 8 +2.8
9 Kansas City Chiefs 8 +2.7
10 Green Bay Packers 9 +2.4

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Jacksonville Jaguars to do one thing, and over 8 games they did +8.9 points per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamespoints per game vs expected
1 Los Angeles Chargers 8 -9.6
2 Philadelphia Eagles 9 -6.9
3 Baltimore Ravens 9 -6.4
4 Indianapolis Colts 9 -4.7
5 New Orleans Saints 8 -2.5
6 Arizona Cardinals 9 -2.2
7 Carolina Panthers 8 -2.1
8 New York Jets 9 -1.9
9 Dallas Cowboys 9 -1.8
10 Miami Dolphins 8 -1.8

Football (Serie A)

18 teams, 176 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are goals per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 AS Roma 9 +1.4
2 Lazio 11 +1.3
3 Frosinone 10 +1.2
4 Bologna 9 +0.3
5 Como 10 +0.3
6 AC Milan 9 +0.1
7 Napoli 10 +0.1
8 Torino 11 +0.0
9 Cagliari 9 -0.1

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected AS Roma to do one thing, and over 9 games they did +1.4 goals per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Udinese 10 -1.0
2 Fiorentina 9 -0.8
3 Sassuolo 10 -0.8
4 Juventus 10 -0.7
5 Venezia 9 -0.6
6 Parma 9 -0.3
7 Lecce 11 -0.3
8 Genoa 11 -0.2
9 Monza 9 -0.2

Football (Premier League)

18 teams, 160 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are goals per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Hull City 10 +1.0
2 Brentford 8 +0.6
3 Leeds United 8 +0.6
4 Coventry City 9 +0.4
5 Aston Villa 9 +0.3
6 Arsenal 9 +0.3
7 Everton 9 +0.3
8 Ipswich Town 9 +0.3
9 Manchester City 8 -0.1

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Hull City to do one thing, and over 10 games they did +1.0 goal per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Manchester United 9 -0.7
2 Chelsea 8 -0.7
3 Crystal Palace 9 -0.6
4 Newcastle United 9 -0.4
5 Liverpool 8 -0.4
6 Tottenham Hotspur 10 -0.3
7 Sunderland 8 -0.3
8 Nottingham Forest 10 -0.2
9 Fulham 10 -0.2

Football (La Liga)

15 teams, 122 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are goals per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Espanyol 8 +0.5
2 Atlético Madrid 7 +0.5
3 Real Betis 8 +0.4
4 Barcelona 7 +0.4
5 Real Sociedad 8 +0.3
6 Real Madrid 10 +0.3
7 Rayo Vallecano 7 +0.2

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Espanyol to do one thing, and over 8 games they did +0.5 goal per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Sevilla 9 -0.5
2 Valencia 7 -0.5
3 Málaga 9 -0.4
4 Levante 8 -0.4
5 Celta Vigo 8 -0.3
6 Getafe 8 -0.2
7 Alavés 9 -0.1

Football (Ligue 1)

12 teams, 74 team-games with a closing line. Numbers are goals per game.

Most underrated — they delivered more than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Brest 5 +1.4
2 Marseille 6 +0.9
3 Paris FC 6 +0.8
4 Nice 7 +0.3
5 Lille 6 +0.3
6 Lyon 5 +0.2

Read the top line like this: the betting market expected Brest to do one thing, and over 5 games they did +1.4 goals per game better than that.

Most overrated — they delivered less than the market expected

#TeamGamesgoals per game vs expected
1 Angers 7 -1.1
2 Troyes 6 -0.9
3 AS Monaco 6 -0.7
4 Toulouse 7 -0.4
5 Strasbourg 6 -0.3
6 Lorient 7 -0.1

What this is good for, and what it is not

This is a look back, not a tip. A team being underrated all season does not mean the next game is priced wrong — the market reads these tables too, and it moves. Treat it as a season story: who quietly did more than anyone asked, and who kept coming up short.

How this was put together

  • Games: finished 2026-season games only, full-time score.
  • Expected margin: the closing handicap for that team, taken from the line with the most bookmakers behind it. Licensed Australian and United States bookmakers only.
  • Matching: a game counts when the team, the opponent and the date all line up.
  • Minimum: five matched games for a team, and eight such teams for a league to be shown at all.
  • Leagues not here yet simply do not have enough finished games with a closing handicap on record. They appear as their seasons fill out.

Limits, said plainly. Our record of closing lines starts partway through 2026, so a team's number covers the games we have, not necessarily their whole season. Sports without a handicap market are not covered. Small game counts move a lot — a team on five games is a hint, not a verdict.

Reusing this

Published under CC BY 4.0. Quote it, chart it or build on it, including commercially, with credit.

Bet Better (2026). The most overrated and underrated teams of 2026. https://betbetter.world/studies/overrated-underrated-teams

Companion research: Do betting odds tell the truth? · How lines move before kick-off · The daily Margin Index

18+. Gambling involves risk and most people lose money. Nothing here is betting advice. If gambling is causing you harm, support is available at Gambling Help Online (AU) or 1-800-GAMBLER (US).

Get tomorrow's free pick by email

Free. One email a day, tops. Unsubscribe in one tap.

18+ only. Please gamble responsibly.