Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Prediction & Picks, October 25, 2026

The Dallas Stars have been strong lately, winning 6 of their last 10 games. They have also been good at keeping opponents from scoring, blocking 15.1 shots each game. The New York Islanders are not far behind, winning 5 of their last 10 and landing 23.6 hits per game, showing they can be physical. This matchup is likely to be tight, which makes the total goals pick interesting. Betting on under 5.5 goals seems smart because both teams have solid defenses and their recent games suggest lower-scoring outcomes. The expected total is close to 5.8, so it's a tight call. The main risk here is that both teams are capable of surprising each other offensively, making this a close one to watch.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: New York Islanders +1.5 Puck Line (-154)

The bet on New York Islanders +1.5 at -154 offers solid value for this matchup. The Islanders have won 5 of their last 10 games, showing they can compete against tough teams. Their ability to land 23.6 hits a game suggests they play with energy, which can be crucial against a strong team like the Dallas Stars. While the Stars have performed well, winning 6 of their last 10, it's important to note that both teams are closely matched. The Islanders have also been good at blocking shots, allowing them to stay in games. With the Islanders getting the extra goal, this bet looks promising, but the risk lies in the Stars being tough to beat at home.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: New York Islanders 3rd Period 3-Way Moneyline (+220)

The odds are offering a good price on the New York Islanders at +220, making them an interesting underdog pick. They have won 5 of their last 10 games, and while they may not have the best shot-blocking numbers, they are known for landing plenty of hits, averaging 23.6 per game. This physical style could really pay off in the third period. The Dallas Stars have been solid with 6 wins in their last 10, but they also let teams create chances. The Islanders are definitely capable of taking advantage of this, especially if they keep up their hitting game. The biggest risk here is that both teams are pretty close in form, so it could go either way.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Brayden Schenn Over 0.5 Points (+140)

Brayden Schenn has a solid chance to get at least one point against the New York Islanders, especially since the Dallas Stars are playing well lately, winning 6 of their last 10 games. Schenn has been a key player for Dallas, and with the Islanders allowing a fair number of shots, he could find opportunities to score or assist. The risk here is that both teams are quite close in skill, making it tricky to predict outcomes. Still, with Schenn's recent form and the Stars' strong performance at home, betting on him to get over 0.5 points feels like a smart play.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Bo Horvat Over 0.5 Assists (+175)

Bo Horvat has been making a big impact lately, and he's been getting plenty of chances to assist his teammates. With Dallas blocking a lot of shots, he might find openings to set up plays. The Stars are tough, but they also give up chances, especially with their recent defensive style. While the Islanders have won five of their last ten, they have a solid chance to score, and Horvat is right in the middle of it all. The biggest risk is how evenly matched these teams are right now, making it hard to predict exactly how the game will unfold. Still, betting on Horvat to get at least one assist seems like a good shot.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Tyler Seguin Under 2.5 Shots on Goal (-185)

The odds for Tyler Seguin to have under 2.5 shots on goal are looking pretty good at -185. The Dallas Stars have won 6 of their last 10 games, showing they're in decent form. They've been strong defensively, blocking 15.1 shots per game, better than the league average. Seguin might find it tough to get his shots off against a solid Islanders team that also blocks well, averaging 13.1 shots blocked per game. One thing to consider is that Seguin is still a key player, and he can surprise us. However, with the Stars focusing on their defensive game and the Islanders being tough to break down, it makes sense to lean towards him not hitting that 2.5 mark tonight. It should be an interesting matchup at the American Airlines Center!

That is the full board for this game. Prices can move before you get on, so check the board at your bookmaker. Bet what you can afford to lose. If betting stops being fun, take a break.