Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders Prediction & Picks, October 25, 2026

The Dallas Stars are playing well lately, winning 6 of their last 10 games. Their defense has been solid, blocking about 15 shots a game, which is better than the league average. Meanwhile, the New York Islanders have also shown some strength, winning 5 of their last 10, but they block fewer shots than the Stars. Their hits per game are higher, which might suggest a more aggressive style, but that could also lead to penalties. Given these stats, a bet on under 5.5 total goals feels like a smart choice. Both teams are finding ways to protect their net well, and the expected combined total is just shy of 6 goals. The biggest risk here is how close the teams are in performance; a single slip could swing the game.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: New York Islanders +0.5 3rd Period Puck Line (-130)

The price on New York Islanders +0.5 in the third period looks appealing here. Both teams are fairly close in their recent form, with the Islanders winning 5 of their last 10 games, while the Stars have pulled off 6 wins in the same stretch. The Islanders have been tough on defense, blocking fewer shots per game than the league average, which shows they can hold their own. The risk is that both teams are evenly matched, making this a pretty tight contest. The Stars have been slightly more physical with their hits, but the Islanders are playing well enough to keep it close. This bet feels like a good chance to take, especially with how competitive both sides have been lately.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: New York Islanders 2nd Period Moneyline (+140)

The odds for the New York Islanders to win the second period are at +140, which offers solid value. They have been pretty competitive lately, winning 5 of their last 10 games. While the Dallas Stars have had some success too, our numbers show this matchup is very close, almost like a coin flip. The Islanders are landing more hits per game than the league average, showing they can be tough on the ice. However, their shot-blocking is a bit lower than Dallas's, which could be a concern. With both teams being so evenly matched, this one could go either way, but the potential payout for the Islanders makes it an interesting choice.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Bo Horvat Over 2.5 Shots on Goal (-105)

Bo Horvat has been a solid player for the New York Islanders, and he's been getting his shots off regularly. In the last 10 games, he's been involved in a lot of action on the ice, contributing to the Islanders' offense. The Dallas Stars have been blocking a good number of shots, but Horvat's chances to hit over 2.5 shots on goal look promising. The Stars have won 6 of their last 10 games, showing good form, but they also allow players to get their shots off. If Horvat finds his rhythm, he could easily break that mark. The biggest risk is that both teams are closely matched, so things could get tight. Still, the odds are in favor of Horvat getting those shots tonight.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Bo Horvat Over 0.5 Assists (+176)

Bo Horvat is looking good to help his team connect with some assists. He's been in the mix lately, and with Dallas giving up chances, this could be a perfect spot for him. The Stars have won six of their last ten games and are letting plenty of shots come through, which can lead to setup chances. While both teams are playing well, there's a real chance this could go either way since the matchup is tight. The Islanders have been blocking fewer shots than average, so Horvat might find those opportunities to dish out an assist. Just keep in mind, if the game gets tight, scoring chances can dry up quickly.

Dallas Stars vs New York Islanders: Mikko Rantanen Under 1.5 Points (-233)

The odds for Mikko Rantanen to score under 1.5 points are looking pretty solid at -233. The Dallas Stars have been doing well lately, winning 6 of their last 10 games, and they've also shown strong defensive skills, blocking more shots than the average team. This makes it tough for opponents to rack up points, which is important for Rantanen's chances. On the other hand, the New York Islanders have won 5 of their last 10 games but haven't been as good at blocking shots. With both teams playing hard, this matchup could be close. The main risk is that Rantanen has the ability to score, so we can't guarantee he won't find the net. Overall, the numbers suggest this is a good bet.

That is everything our model likes in this game. Prices can move before you get on, so check the board at your bookmaker. Bet what you can afford to lose. If betting stops being fun, take a break.