Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers Prediction & Picks, October 9, 2026

The Washington Capitals have been strong lately, winning seven out of their last ten games. However, they're facing a New York Rangers team that has also been solid, with six wins in their last ten. Betting on the New York Rangers to win the second period could pay off. They've got a strong lineup with a good mix of shooters, and they'll be looking to build on their recent success. One risk is that both teams are playing well, which makes this a tough call. But with the odds at +112, it's a chance worth taking.

Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers: Over 5.5 Total Goals (-120)

The Washington Capitals have been on a roll lately, winning 7 of their last 10 games. They've got a solid lineup, and with most of their players shooting left, they can create some tricky plays for the New York Rangers. The Rangers have also been strong, winning 6 of their last 10, so this matchup looks pretty even overall. Betting on over 5.5 total goals seems like a smart choice. Both teams have been scoring well, and our numbers suggest they're likely to combine for about 6 goals. The biggest risk is how closely matched they are, but with both teams in good form, this should be an exciting game with plenty of action.

Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers: New York Rangers 3rd Period Moneyline (+124)

The New York Rangers and Washington Capitals are both playing well, with the Rangers winning 6 of their last 10 and the Capitals winning 7 of their last 10. This matchup is tight, and it's almost like a coin flip, but the Rangers have shown they can take control in crucial moments. Betting on the Rangers to win the third period could be a smart choice. They have a slight advantage in skater numbers and have been pretty solid on the road. The biggest risk here is that both teams are so evenly matched that it could come down to the last few minutes of play.

Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers: Igor Shesterkin Under 26.5 Saves (-115)

The bet on Igor Shesterkin to make under 26.5 saves looks solid at -115 odds. The Washington Capitals have been scoring well lately, winning 7 of their last 10 games, which means Shesterkin might not face too many shots. Plus, with the Capitals playing at home, they could control the game and keep the Rangers on the defensive. While the New York Rangers have also won 6 of their last 10, their scoring hasn't been as strong lately. The risk here is that both teams are quite close in skill, and if the game turns out to be more balanced, Shesterkin could end up facing more shots than we hope. Still, the numbers suggest a good chance for this pick.

Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers: Logan Thompson Over 21.5 Saves (-125)

Logan Thompson is in goal for the Washington Capitals, and he's been busy lately. The Capitals have won seven of their last ten games, showing strong form, but that means Thompson is likely to face a lot of shots from the New York Rangers, who have also won six of their last ten. This matchup has the potential for some action, and Thompson's saves should add up quickly. With both teams shooting left a lot, Thompson will have chances to rack up his save count. The Rangers are known for their offensive pressure, and that could lead to Thompson making over 21.5 saves in this game. The biggest risk is that the game could turn into a blowout, but given the close records, it seems more likely that Thompson will be busy.

Washington Capitals vs New York Rangers: Adam Fox Under 1.5 Blocked Shots (-130)

The Washington Capitals have been on a roll lately, winning 7 of their last 10 games. They've got a strong offense and are tough to break down at home. Adam Fox from the New York Rangers might find it tricky to get more than one blocked shot in this matchup. The Capitals are good at shutting down plays, especially with their sharp defensive game. Betting on Adam Fox to have under 1.5 blocked shots seems smart here. While he's a solid player, the Capitals' strong pressure could limit his chances. The risk is that the game stays close, which could lead to more action on the ice. Overall, this bet has a good chance of hitting based on how well the Capitals have been playing.

That is our read — no bet on this board is a sure thing. Prices can move before you get on, so check the board at your bookmaker. Bet what you can afford to lose. If betting stops being fun, take a break.