Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders Prediction & Picks, October 17, 2026

The New York Islanders need to outplay the Toronto Maple Leafs to win tonight. The players on both sides are still getting into the groove this season, and that makes this matchup feel like a toss-up. The biggest risk here is the close competition; both teams are finding their rhythm and can take advantage of each other's mistakes. However, given the Islanders' recent form and the fact that they've been scoring better lately, they have a good chance to pull off the win at these odds.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders: Over 6.5 Total Goals (+105)

The odds of over 6.5 goals at +105 look appealing for this matchup between the Toronto Maple Leafs and the New York Islanders. Both teams have had mixed results lately, with the Leafs winning only 3 of their last 10 and the Islanders winning 4. This game could see plenty of action, especially since the scoring could be boosted by the Leafs' left-handed shooters. However, the combined expected total is around 6.0, which makes this bet a bit risky as it's very tight. With both teams fighting for wins, they might play a little more cautiously. Still, with a bit of luck, we could see some goals fly in at Scotiabank Arena.

Toronto Maple Leafs vs New York Islanders: New York Islanders 3-Way Moneyline (+170)

The New York Islanders need to win tonight against the Toronto Maple Leafs for this bet to pay off. The Islanders have been a bit better lately, winning 4 of their last 10 games, while the Maple Leafs have only managed 3 wins in the same stretch. This matchup is pretty close, but the Islanders have a solid chance to pull off the upset. Playing at Scotiabank Arena might help the Maple Leafs, but the Islanders have shown they can compete well. With the odds at +170, taking a shot on the Islanders feels like a good risk. Just remember, the Leafs are always tough at home, so it won't be easy for New York.

That is the whole read on this one. Prices can move before you get on, so check the board at your bookmaker. Bet what you can afford to lose. If betting stops being fun, take a break.